Wednesday, October 15, 2008

The death of Richard Cooey

The prisoner who claimed that he was too fat to be humanely executed by lethal injection was nonetheless put to death by this method in Ohio yesterday. Richard Cooey, aged 41, killed two students from an Ohio university twenty-two years ago. His final appeal was rejected by the US Supreme Court on Tuesday. Cooey and Clinton Dickens, his 17-year-old accomplice, were found guilty of the murders of Wendy Offredo and Dawn McCreery. The two men had been throwing concrete slabs from a bridge onto a main road. One of them struck Ms Offredo's car.

Worse, they pretended to "rescue" the women and took the victims to a remote field where they subjected them to three-and-a-half-hours of rape, torture, stabbing, and fatal bludgeoning. Cooey carved an "X" into the stomachs of both women.

Each man blamed the other for delivering the fatal blows, but both were convicted of murder. Dickens received a life sentence because of his age.

Six of Dawn McCreery's family members watched quietly as the execution took place. Mary Ann Hackenberg, mother of the 20-year old student, looked to the ceiling and let out a sigh when Cooey's death was announced at 10:28am local time.

Summit County Prosecutor Sherri Bevan Walsh said the family was disappointed that Cooey was vulgar and hateful to the end. "He still would not apologize and still would not accept responsibility for what he did," she said.

It is a terrible thing to take the life of another human being. For the state to do it in the name of its citizens is an awesome thing. The frightening possiblity that an innocent man might be executed would hold us back from rushing precipitously to the death penalty.

But then again, there are some crimes so horrible and some criminals so unrepentent
that they deserve death. The victim's blood cries out to us from the ground.

The American system of state executions, where numerous rounds of appeals and stays of execution at least give the murderer time to regret and repent, certainly has its critics. It is said that in the UK you get a life sentence for murder; in China you get the death penalty, but in the USA, first you get a life sentence and then you get the death penalty.

I find it strange that people who encourage the putting to death of babies in the womb lest they become an encumbrance to their irresponsible mothers, and who wish to put away old people who have outlived their 'usefulness', should wish to preserve the lives of monsters like Cooey.

I know hard cases make bad law and that there may well be grey areas concerning abortion, euthanasia and capital punishment that could be argued about, but would anybody like to stand up and say to Mrs Hackenberg that her daughter's killer should not have been executed?

5 comments:

jan said...

your site is simply rocking!!!!!!!!1
keep going
have a look at ma blogs..
lance and dude

Anonymous said...

"I find it strange that people who encourage the putting to death of babies in the womb lest they become an encumbrance to their irresponsible mothers, and who wish to put away old people who have outlived their 'usefulness', should wish to preserve the lives of monsters like Cooey."

I do too. But equally strange are those anti-abortionist's who espouse the "value of life" but chomp at the bit in anticipation of an execution.

Words of caution - there is one judge-GOD.

Anonymous said...

Heinous murder, especially without repentance is the one certain instance in my mind where the Biblical "eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth" most definitely seems appropriate. I do believe that some killers do honestly repent, but psychopaths almost never can be meaningfully rehabilitated.

DWCLL

Anonymous said...

Anonymous #2:

No one 'chomps at the bit' concerning an execution. Liberals such as you love to exaggerate and put words into the mouths of your enemies.

I find it more terrible that you find no problem in killing innocent babies, yet defend monsters full of evil.

Luckily, most Americans disagree with you.

I live in California. I envy states such as Texas and Florida where executions are easier to effect, and justice is administered with awesome finality.

BTW, it has been proven over and over again that the death penalty deters others from committing capital crimes.

Anonymous said...

anonymous # 2, I am the one who said "chomp at the bit". I am the so-called "liberal". I am the one who allegedly and in your eyes conclusively "finds no problems killing innocent babies". I am the one who defends "monsters full of evil".

You have proven my point and implore you re-read the New Testament if indeed you are a Chrisitan.

You are right "it has been proven over and over again that the death penalty deters others from committing capital crimes" Just look at Muslim countries for proof.

I reiterate my cautionary advice - there is one judge - God.